← Back to course

Tar PitIdea Checker

A "tar pit idea" is a business idea that sounds obviously good — everyone nods when you pitch it — but has already been tried by dozens (sometimes hundreds) of founders and structurally fails for the same reasons every time. They are dangerous precisely because they feel validated: friends love the pitch, the problem is real and relatable, and the MVP looks easy to build. The trap is a structural one (no defensible market, no real willingness to pay, a network-effect problem, a distribution problem, a "the incumbent will just copy this" problem) that no amount of good execution fixes.

If your idea matches something on this list — or is a thin variation of it — treat that as a strong signal to dig deeper before committing the course to it. Not automatically disqualifying, but you'll need a very clear answer to: what's structurally different this time, who else has tried this and failed, and why will your team succeed where they didn't?

Check your idea

Pitch it in a few sentences — the AI checks the list and the wider startup graveyard

How harsh should the check be?
0/1000

Non tar pit startups from alumni and founders

Examples from alumni and founders that aren't tar pit ideas

Well-Aware (formerly Binqy)

An employee-understanding platform for HR and leadership teams, combining scientifically-validated surveys (MTO, PMO, eNPS, RI&E), anonymous speak-up channels, and psychologist access. Integrates directly with HR systems like AFAS and Workday, and now serves 150+ HR teams including named enterprise clients.

well-aware.com

Veridis Instruments

Developer of MADSCAN, a patented thermal-analysis technology that gives recyclers over 99% accurate insight into the composition of complex, mixed plastic waste streams — including dark plastics that optical sorting can't identify. Sold as industrial-scale analysis machines to recycling and chemical-recycling facilities across Europe.

veridis.tech

SRXP Mobile Expense Reporting (sold to Exact)

A mobile and web expense-reporting tool that lets employees capture receipts and mileage, routes them through manager approval, and exports directly into a company's financial system. Used by thousands of companies across 90+ countries, and later acquired by Exact.

srxp.com

Heart Harmona

A digital self-management tool for heart failure patients, built with cardiologists and nurses to turn complex care plans into simple daily actions around medication adherence, symptom monitoring, and emotional support. Bridges the fragile transition from hospital to home, where relapse and readmission risk is highest.

heartharmona.com

Realite

Property-management software for landlords, managers, and investors, covering administration, maintenance, leasing, and financial reporting in one platform. Integrates with Dutch government property registries and major mortgage lenders, giving it a compliance and financial-infrastructure moat beyond a typical rental marketplace.

realite.com

MadGlove

A wearable orthotic glove that helps people with hand spasticity — often stroke or brain-injury survivors — regain hand function and independence through home-based rehabilitation. Its modular finger sleeves let therapists and patients tailor support precisely to individual severity and daily needs.

madglove.com

storks.ai (Storks of Amsterdam)

A robotics lab building autonomous drones, IoT devices, and robotic swarms to create high-resolution environmental models, such as tracking CO2 and phosphate emissions. Their mission is understanding human impact on ecosystems with minimal physical intervention.

storks.amsterdam

FLAME AWAY

A decorative, throwable fire extinguisher designed to be kept in plain sight rather than hidden in a cupboard, so anyone — including children and the elderly — can react within seconds of a fire starting. Thrown into the flames, it shatters and releases a water-based extinguishing solution that's safe to touch and easy to clean up.

flameaway.nl

The list of tar pit ideas

Businesses you should probably not create!

110 ideas across 9 categories — click to unfold

How to use this list+

If your idea lands on or close to this list, it doesn't mean automatic rejection — a few genuinely became large companies (Strava, Doximity, Linear, Calendly). But those exceptions won by finding a non-obvious structural wedge: a hardware habit, a regulatory angle, a vertical-specific workflow, or a distribution channel the graveyard of previous attempts didn't have.

  1. What's structurally different now? ("We used AI" is not a structural difference on its own.)
  2. Who has already tried this, and why exactly did they fail? (If you can't name at least 2–3 prior attempts and their specific failure reason, you haven't done enough desk research yet.)
  3. What's your unfair distribution advantage? ("We'll market it well" is not an advantage — a channel, a partnership, a proprietary dataset, or an existing community is.)
01 · 15 ideasGeneric consumer "connector" & social apps+

The classic trap: "an app that connects [group] with [other group]." These almost always fail on cold-start (nobody shows up until everyone does) and on frequency (people don't need it often enough to build a habit).

  • Sports buddy / workout partner matching app
  • Study buddy / accountability partner app
  • Roommate / housemate finder app
  • Friend-making app for new-in-town people
  • App for making plans with friends (group polls, shared calendars, RSVPs)
  • Networking app for young professionals
  • Mentor-mentee matching platform
  • Language exchange / practice partner app
  • Hobby-based meetup app ("Meetup, but better")
  • App to combat loneliness among the elderly
  • Volunteer-to-cause matching platform
  • Dating app with a "smarter" matching algorithm
  • App to find a co-founder / business partner
  • Pen pal / long-distance friendship app
  • App for parents to organize playdates
02 · 15 ideasCampus / student-life specific ideas+

Same "connector" trap, but scoped to a university campus. Very common in student courses — almost always tried before, on this exact campus or another one.

  • Campus “super-app” (events, tutoring, marketplace, social — all in one)
  • Second-hand textbook marketplace
  • Peer-to-peer tutoring platform
  • Campus food/coffee delivery app
  • Student discount aggregator app
  • Note-sharing / lecture notes marketplace
  • Internship or side-gig matching app for students
  • Student event discovery app
  • Dorm/room decor or subletting marketplace
  • Campus ride-sharing / carpool app
  • Laundry pickup service for students
  • Student mental health check-in app
  • Course/professor review platform ("RateMyProfessor, but new")
  • Study group formation app
  • Student-only marketplace for buying/selling used items
03 · 15 ideas"Uber for X" / local services marketplaces+

Looks like software eating an inefficient offline market. In practice: providers disintermediate you after the first job, demand is too infrequent to build habit/LTV, and trust is local, not app-based.

  • Uber for house cleaning
  • Uber for handymen / home repairs
  • Uber for dog walking
  • Uber for personal training
  • Uber for freelance photographers
  • Uber for tutoring
  • Uber for babysitting/childcare
  • Uber for beauty services (mobile hairdresser/manicure)
  • Uber for moving/removals
  • On-demand laundry/dry cleaning pickup
  • On-demand car wash
  • Marketplace for local handmade goods ("a better Etsy")
  • A modern, cleaner Craigslist / classifieds site
  • Neighborhood/hyperlocal social network ("Nextdoor, but nicer")
  • Local errand-running app
04 · 13 ideasGeneric physical products / CPG+

The market may be enormous, but it's also brutally crowded, has near-zero differentiation, and margins live and die on distribution and shelf space — not on the founders' insight.

  • A new soft drink / energy drink brand
  • A new clothing brand / fashion line
  • A new protein bar / snack brand
  • A new bottled water brand
  • Athleisure or streetwear line
  • A new coffee brand
  • A "healthier" version of an existing snack category
  • Reusable water bottle / eco-friendly merchandise line
  • Subscription box for [any consumer category]
  • Private-label skincare or cosmetics line
  • A new sneaker brand
  • Candle or home-fragrance brand
  • A new phone case / accessory brand
05 · 10 ideasSustainability & "green" ideas with no real business model behind the mission+

The intent is good, but "sustainable" alone isn't a business model — these frequently rediscover that willingness to pay for "green" is much lower than survey respondents claim.

  • App to track your personal carbon footprint
  • Platform to offset your carbon footprint via donations
  • Reusable packaging / container-swap service
  • App connecting local farmers directly to consumers
  • Food-waste-reduction app (surplus restaurant food marketplace)
  • Peer-to-peer clothing swap/rental platform
  • Eco-friendly cleaning products brand
  • Bike-share or micromobility platform (new city entrant)
  • Platform to plant a tree for every purchase
  • Reusable coffee cup deposit/return network
06 · 14 ideasGeneric "better [incumbent]" software ideas+

The incumbent already owns distribution, is free or bundled, and can ship your one differentiating feature in an update. These rarely die from bad execution — they die from structure.

  • A better to-do list / productivity app
  • A better email client
  • A better calendar app / AI scheduling assistant
  • A better note-taking app
  • A new group chat / messaging app
  • "Instagram, but for [niche]"
  • A personalized news aggregator app
  • A Q&A / expert-advice platform
  • A music discovery app ("a better Spotify algorithm")
  • Password manager (new entrant, no real differentiation)
  • A new project management tool for small teams
  • A budgeting/personal finance app (undifferentiated)
  • A recipe discovery / meal-planning app
  • Habit tracker app
07 · 8 ideasGeneric marketplace/platform ideas without a real wedge+

"Two-sided marketplace" sounds scalable, but without a specific liquidity/trust wedge these all suffer the same chicken-and-egg problem and disintermediation risk.

  • General freelancer marketplace ("Fiverr, but curated")
  • Marketplace for renting out unused personal items
  • General event-planning marketplace
  • Wedding-vendor marketplace (undifferentiated)
  • Marketplace for pet services generally
  • General B2B services marketplace ("find any contractor")
  • Marketplace for secondhand furniture
  • General influencer/brand matchmaking platform
08 · 12 ideasGeneric AI-wrapper ideas (2025–2026 wave)+

The current version of the trap: a thin interface on top of a foundation model API, with no data moat, no distribution advantage, and a defeater that's usually "the model vendor ships this natively within a year."

  • Generic AI chatbot for customer support (no vertical focus)
  • AI SDR / autonomous outbound sales agent
  • AI note-taker / meeting summarizer (generic, not vertical-specific)
  • "No-code AI agent builder" platform
  • AI recruiter / autonomous candidate sourcing and screening
  • AI voice agent for generic call-center replacement
  • AI companion / AI girlfriend-boyfriend app
  • AI-generated content/marketing copy tool (generic, undifferentiated)
  • AI resume builder / cover letter generator
  • Generic "ChatGPT wrapper" for [any everyday task]
  • AI-powered generic personal assistant app
  • AI study buddy / homework helper (generic, not curriculum-specific)
09 · 8 ideasOther perennial student favorites+

Recurring favourites in student venture programs — familiar, easy to pitch, and repeatedly attempted.

  • Peer-to-peer skill-sharing platform ("Airbnb for skills")
  • General freelance/gig marketplace for students
  • App gamifying personal finance/saving for young people
  • Social platform for book lovers ("Goodreads, but better")
  • Travel-planning/itinerary app (generic, not a specific wedge)
  • General fitness/workout app (undifferentiated content library)
  • App to reduce screen time / digital wellbeing (generic)
  • Marketplace connecting startups with student freelancers/interns (generic, unless clearly differentiated)